Mayor Jacob Frey rallies votes to save Bill Peterson's nomination as Minneapolis police chief
Published in News & Features
MINNEAPOLIS — Mayor Jacob Frey and his political allies are working behind the scenes to salvage his nominee for Minneapolis police chief following an unprecedented rejection last week.
Interim Chief Bill Peterson, a 31-year department veteran, has signaled a desire to remain in the running for the top job, which would require at least two City Council members to switch their positions on Frey’s preferred internal candidate.
The council denied Peterson the permanent role in an 8-5 vote last week, following a lengthy public job interview in which several progressives skewered him for failing to identify specific examples of racist, sexist, homophobic or discriminatory behavior observed over his three decades on the force.
Two moderate Democrats, typically reliable police supporters who each represent North Side wards, ultimately broke ranks with the mayor to derail Peterson’s bid.
LaTrisha Vetaw, a longtime ally of Frey, noted that she does not dislike Peterson but preferred another finalist who she believes is more qualified: Deputy Chief of Investigations Charlie Adams, a North Side native long entrenched in the community.
Meanwhile, Council Member Pearll Warren took issue with Peterson’s two open misconduct complaints.
“My position is not personal,” she later wrote on Facebook. “It is principled.”
The rejection of Peterson caught many by surprise, even within City Hall. Retired law enforcement and Peterson’s supporters sounded off on social media, castigating the 13-member council for how they treated a largely unblemished nominee.
Many also expressed fears about the department’s long-term future and opined that fewer experienced officers will want to apply.
After taking the weekend to mull it over, Peterson told Frey that he was committed to leading the department into the future and willing to stay the nominee, according to people familiar with the matter.
Now the Frey administration is scrambling to whip votes in favor of Peterson, his most important Cabinet appointment this term. Specifically, he’s angling to sway Vetaw and Warren to give him the narrow majority.
Frey vetoed the council’s previous action late Thursday, which effectively keeps Peterson’s nomination alive.
But some frustrated observers want a do-over.
Unity Community Mediation Team, a diverse group of south Minneapolis residents and business owners, penned a letter to Frey this week criticizing his intervention in the search process.
“By appearing to have moved a favored candidate late into this process and including only a very few community members in the later stages of the process, you have hurt your reputation for community engagement with our most justice-impacted communities, and you have severely damaged the trust our residents placed in you in the last election,” wrote the Rev. Ian Bethel.
Yet Peterson is getting overwhelming support from his peers.
On Monday morning, law enforcement executives from across the Twin Cities metro gathered at the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, or BCA, headquarters in St. Paul to discuss gang violence.
During the meeting, BCA Superintendent Drew Evans praised Peterson for his leadership since taking control of MPD in May. Dozens of fellow police chiefs and high-ranking officials encouraged him to continue seeking the job, if he still wanted it. Some even gave him a standing ovation.
“Everybody knows him and respects him,” said Ramsey County Undersheriff Mike Martin, a retired Minneapolis police commander who attended the meeting. “If I didn’t have 100% confidence in his abilities, I wouldn’t support him, because the city is too important for that.”
Later that afternoon, Frey sent an email to MPD’s officers and civilian staff emphasizing his desire that Peterson eventually be confirmed.
“Going forward, I want to be clear that Interim Chief Peterson remains in charge of the department, and he has my full support,” according to an email obtained by The Minnesota Star Tribune. “He will continue serving as Interim Chief, and it is my continued hope that he will become the permanent chief of the Minneapolis Police Department.”
At a weekly meeting Thursday, where department commanders gather to discuss crime-fighting strategies and analyze crime trends, Peterson sought to address the elephant in the room.
He told his staff that he was exhausted after two marathon hearings but was attempting to stay positive and keep his head up, people familiar with his comments told the Star Tribune. Peterson also reiterated his commitment to the agency, regardless of where he lands.
The City Council is expected to consider overriding Frey’s veto during a special Friday meeting. They’re unlikely to have the nine votes needed to override and defeat Peterson’s appointment, putting the nominee in indefinite limbo.
At that point, someone could move to approve Peterson’s nomination, or the council could postpone that to a future meeting.
Minneapolis City Clerk Casey Carl said the nomination then would be in a gray area until the council takes “dispositive” action that brings finality to the situation, such as overriding the mayor. The city charter seems to require city leaders to find compromise, he said.
“I actually think it’s sort of brilliant,” Carl said. “It says both sides of this government need to come to the table and find a way to work together, even when it’s hard.”
As if that isn’t complicated enough, the charter also says if three mayoral nominations are rejected for a position, the council can bring its own slate of three candidates, from which the mayor would have to choose one as a nominee, who have to be approved by the council.
“It’s never been done,” Carl said. “We (would be) in unchartered charter territory in that we would not know how to do that. We would be having to make up the process, which is just kind of described generally by the charter. We would have to put some meat on those bones.”
©2026 The Minnesota Star Tribune. Visit startribune.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC







Comments