Karen Read trial figure 'Turtleboy' remains out on bail, trial date postponed
Published in News & Features
BOSTON — Aidan Kearney, a blogger known as “Turtleboy” accused of witness intimidation related to the Karen Read case, survived a bail revocation motion during a raucous hearing disrupted continuously by online viewers.
“Shut the Zoom off,” Judge Christopher Belezos said after yet another disruption from a viewer on the teleconference program.
Belezos had issued repeated warnings to viewers on Zoom, which allowed for remote access to the hearing held Thursday morning at Suffolk Superior Court in Boston. The last disruption came as a soundbite of a woman saying “you hit like a (expletive)” repeated on a loop at least twice before the judge made the call to shut off remote access.
The outburst mirrored the circus-like behaviors surrounding the two trials of Karen Read, who had been charged with the murder of her Boston Police Officer boyfriend John O’Keefe in January of 2022, for which she was acquitted at her second trial in the summer of 2025.
Members of O’Keefe’s family filed a civil suit against Read for his death, a case that remains pending in Plymouth Superior Court.
Kearney was a devoted supporter of Read’s innocence and was the de facto head of the “Free Karen Read” movement that saw throngs of supporters at every court hearing — so many that the trial judge imposed buffer zones for protesting around the courthouse.
But prosecutors argue that Kearney’s activism transcended the confines of the law, including through direct confrontations in the real world and not just in his online work against witnesses for the prosecution. He faces six felony charges of witness intimidation and three felony charges of picketing jurors.
The judge also postponed Kearney’s trial until February of next year, citing a violent crimes trial that takes precedence in court trial scheduling.
Ahead of the hearing, Kearney told reporters that he didn’t have much to say about prosecutor Robert Cosgrove’s motion to have his bail revoked, saying that the court date was scheduled to hear motions in limine: “We’re just getting ready for the trial and, other than that, anything’s a distraction.”
Cosgrove, in his motion filed a day before the hearing, argued that Kearney was violating his release by reading in an online broadcast information that was under a protective order — impounded — from public disclosure.
Specifically, Cosgrove wrote, Jennifer McCabe, a witness for the prosecution in the Karen Read murder trials, informed the prosecutor’s office that Kearney had been reading the contents of a forensic extraction from her phone, which is sealed from the public by court order. Cosgrove added that Kearney not only read from the extraction but admitted live to his YouTube viewers that he knew the information was impounded.
Judge Belezos said he would not revoke Kearney’s bail but would impose to his release conditions a concrete restriction from sharing any impounded information.
Cosgrove alleged that Kearney’s violations serve to “further taint the potential jury pool for the defendant’s fast-approaching trial.” He wrote further that he had previously filed motions to revoke bail and that on the last hearing for such notions, Judge Michael Doolin had told Kearney he was on “thin ice.”
“Telling the defendant that from now on he must obey the orders of the court which he has already enthusiastically and knowingly defied obviously will not suffice,” Cosgrove wrote. “This court should revoke his recognizance, or, if it is unwilling to do so, fashion a sanction with suitable teeth.”
Kearney’s attorney Tim Bradl told reporters after the hearing that Cosgrove’s bail revocation motions are “retaliatory” but said Kearney understands the restriction. He also questioned the validity of impounding so much material and considered an effort to create “expiration dates” for impoundment.
“We don’t want them to be used as swords instead of shields,” fellow Kearney defense attorney Mark Bederow added.
“If Aidan stops his journalism, they win,” Bradl told reporters following the hearing. “He knows the rules. We’re not his censor; Mark and I are not his gatekeepers. He’s a grown-up; he knows what to do and not do.”
(Herald photographer Stuart Cahill contributed to this report.)
©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at bostonherald.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments